well sort of anyway.
this was sent by bryne carruthers who did the
Has Denise Minger Read 'The China Study'?
here is the text, an apology from Denise to the “Plant-Based Diet Doctor Squad” (Caldwell Esselstyn, John McDougall, Dean Ornish, Neal Barnard,
Read more…I have created a couple of posts addressing the very serious inaccuracies and flaws in the claims of Denise Minger and the cholesterol skeptics, and have included several hundred references with easily accessible links.
http://healthylongevity.blogspo
Read more…howdy guys!
i have chatted to my dad about this book and recommended it....he has gone as far as buying it but i am hoping that when he gets around to reading it it will inspire him to change his eating habits! It honestly saddens me to think of how l
Read more…Hey guys! I was having a discussion on a blog of a guy named Elliot Hulse (who has quite a following, btw). He promotes a high protein/fat, animal product diet (Weston Price, Paleo/Primal, redneck, etc...).
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JFjdBNn6n2M&f
Read more…Hey guys, please let me know; does anyone have a list of other studies that have similar findings to the China Study proving the vegan diet is healthiest?
Read more…The B-D Debate For Dummies
at long last, the work no one was waiting for, is finally here!
just don't tell rex and audrey, ok?
in friendship,
prad
Scenario
Have you been baffled by what's been going on regarding the China Study discussions over the summer
the campbellcoalition.org site is no longer existent due to restrategizing efforts. some of you never got around to seeing some of the excellent items that were on that site, so nelson campbell has kindly offered to make these available for posting w
Read more…for anyone interested in reading and discussing the china study - this is the place!
it can be done in a scheduled fashion or just randomly.
in any case, this thread should likely be of use to people who haven't read the book.
in friendship,
prad
welcome to bananalysis!
if you have forgotten why you are here, read the original post in this thread:
http://www.30bananasaday.com/group/debunkingthechinastudycritics/forum/topics/bananas-stats-course
otherwise, here's what you can expect from this cou
this is the place to gather together various resources that are useful to the group.
items would include data links, actual data, published papers of specific interest, analytical efforts, links to 'resource oriented' websites.
the idea of this thread
There is an option to begin the Colin Campbell eCornellthree course onlineeducation program for Plant-Based Nutrition tomorrow. If anyone else is taking the courses and would like to exchange ideas or prepare for assignments please respond to this th
Read more…I felt this thread was needed, just to keep all our important responses in one easy-to-find location.
Read more…I'd like to start this thread where we can keep a list of published articles related to diet. Please also list citations that critics of Campbell have included in their arguments. My plan is to obtain the articles, read them, summarize, and (hopefu
Read more…Ok so here are all the major China Study critiques on the web I'm aware of, see below.
We need some volunteers to do concise summaries of the argument and content of these critiques.
We're looking for commonalities in subject matter (there are plenty a
I'd like to know if anyone came across a letter, a post, a message, whatever, from a professional in the field of medicine or epidemiology who openly supported Denise's work? And when I mean openly, I mean someone who signed it with name and title if
Read more…UPDATE: bananalysis is here!
coming soon to your own banana neighborhood!
here's your chance to learn the stats you slept through in school!!
there will be a course in statistical analysis offered right here with the expert guidance of veganmama (and an
this thread will serve as a map for this group so we can find things easily. it will be a good place to point people to if they are trying to find out what's happening regarding this china study criticism debunking.
this original post will be continuo
I don’t have time to review every comment but did quickly scan the text. This analysis seems very impressive, especially given the writer’s young age with no training in nutritional science (see her web page).
She claims to have no biases–either for
Read more…I read part of Denise's on the China Study, and I quickly came to her quick note on stats:
A quick note on stats
Not a math whiz? No problem. The stuff here should be pretty straightforward, but in case you’re rusty or simply allergic to numbers, here’
Read more…